How to Manage Different Types of Difficult Restaurant Customers

By David Scott Peters

·

Since the pandemic many restaurants are telling me tales of some of the most difficult customers I’ve ever heard. The frustration and impatience directed toward restaurant staff seems to be at a whole new level. But the truth is difficult customers have been around forever. The problem today is difficult restaurant customers can do a lot of damage if your team isn’t prepared to handle them because of their access to the internet and social media. Today’s

 “Karens” may be rattling the service industry, but how you handle them is the same as it always has been. In my experience, difficult restaurant customers fall into one of five categories. In this episode of my podcast, The Restaurant Prosperity Formula, I share the five types of difficult restaurant customers, how to identify them in your restaurant, and three skills to develop to best handle the different complaints and problems they present.

I can tell you back in the 1990s, when I was the operations manager for multi-unit brew pub and café here in Phoenix, Arizona, I often had to help with our downtown location on event nights. Our location was downtown next to all the big-time venues that hosted professional sports and concerts, as well as near the convention center. Non-event nights were a whole different experience than event nights or multi-event nights. We would go from zero to literally 300 seats filled. I could never get our owner to reduce our menu on event nights, which would have helped us meet the customers’ needs better. Instead, I was the guy that went out and talked to the customers to turn the situation around. I had the authority to decide whether we were going to comp or not, and so on, but it was no fun.

While I have plenty of stories from that time in my career, everyone in the restaurant industry deals with difficult restaurant customers. For example, my daughter worked as a barista for a chain of coffee places called Dutch Bros. Dutch Bros is known for having the most incredible customer service. Their interview process is really good at identifying the right personality. It’s a happy place with happy baristas. These coffee drive-thrus are busier than you can imagine. There is constantly a line at every location. They pride themselves on great customer service and being quick. I remember her coming home several times at least three separate times talking about how they had to call the police on a guest in line. These were customers who got irate and aggressive, threatening violence – scary stuff.

In your dealings with difficult customers, you might not be at call-the-cops level, but how should you deal with them?

The types of difficult restaurant customers

In my experience, difficult customers fall into five different categories:

  • Complainer
  • Impatient
  • Overly demanding
  • Social butterfly
  • Disruptive

In the podcast episode, I cover how to identify each one of these types.

How you deal with difficult restaurant customers

Empathy, building rapport and communication are critical in dealing with difficult customers.

Empathy is the ability to understand and share the feelings of another person, and it’s essential in dealing with difficult customers because it shows that you care about their concerns.

Communication is essential in dealing with difficult customers because it enables you to explain your position clearly and address any misunderstandings.

Building rapport with customers is essential in dealing with difficult customers because it helps to create a positive relationship and reduce tension.

By demonstrating empathy, communicating clearly, and building rapport with difficult customers, you can create a positive and memorable dining experience that can encourage repeat business and generate positive reviews.

Click the podcast player above to listen in, or you can watch the video on YouTube, click here to download the latest episode. 

Read the full transcript.

Hey there, restaurant pros. I’m David Scott Peters. Welcome to episode 74 of the Restaurant Prosperity Formula. I’ve been coaching restaurant owners since 2003.

And the restaurant prosperity formula is based on what the most successful restaurant owners I’ve worked with do on a daily basis to achieve their success. The basic premise of the formula centers around achieving prosperity, freedom, restaurants and financial freedom you deserve to achieve prosperity you have to follow a very specific formula made up of leadership, systems, training, accountability and taking action. Today I want to talk about how you should go about dealing with difficult customers. Let’s get started.

The beautiful part about being in the restaurant business is that you can create memories for your guests. And for real restaurant pros like you, this is what it’s all about. The unfortunate reality is sometimes those memorable moments well they’re just not always positive or even your fault. Since the pandemic, many restaurants are telling me no tales of some of the most difficult customers I’ve ever heard about or they’ve ever encountered.

I can tell you back in the 1990s when I was the operations manager for a multi unit group of a cafe here in Phoenix, Arizona called Coyote Springs Brewing Company Café. I often had to help with our our downtown location on event nights. So we were literally just blocks away from what the arena the time was where we had the Phoenix Coyotes and the Phoenix Suns would play we have concerts and different events. So it was an event kind of area downtown early on in downtown Phoenix before it got really renovated and working well.

So we would go basically a lot of business people whenever our dinners were light, but when there was an event at night we would go from zero to literally 300 seats filled we’d open up our upstairs banquet facility and put tables in there. We can do that in 45 minutes. And unfortunately, I could never get our owner to reduce our menu on event nights. We’re going to execute what we offer and we’d fall down.

I mean we fall down over and over and over again. And unfortunately fortunately I was the guy that went out and talk to the customers like my managers, my general manager for that location. The assistant manager, the kitchen manager, they all would tuck their tail and go David, would you go talk to table 44 Like it’s no fun taking arrows is it right? Just pick it up right to the heart because you screwed up.

That’s hard enough. But I was that guy who could listen, I was that guy who could turn the turn the situation around. I was that guy who had the authority to decide whether we were going to comp or not and so on. But the truth of the matter is it was no fun.

Now those were just the customers when it was our fault. Then being downtown, we’d had business people we had a lot of people walk in and thought they were they own the world are often difficult to deal with. And again, sometimes I was called to the rescue line. We’ll talk about that.

I can tell you the summer before my daughter went to college or university in high school she had her senior year had gotten in to become a barista for a chain of of coffee places called Dutch Bros. and that’s Broza here on the west coast, midwest area. Like they’re big like they have the most incredible customer service. They go through an interview process.

That is amazing. They only take the top level people rapidly. They took my daughter and they would they have through these lines. They have two lines that go through that people would order they had a welcome window like they pride themselves in great customer service being quick as they can be.

And lots of sugary and coffee drinks. Well teenagers love and that summer alone. I remember coming home several times and I mean several at least three separate times. She talked about how they had to call the police on a guest in line whether in line at the lockup or in their car for crying out loud.

Had the cops because these customers got irate and aggressive, like threatening violence, scary stuff. So what’s the moral of the story? Moral is basically difficult customers has been around forever. That when my mom opened our restaurant in the 1980s but since the pandemic exploded, the number of crappy customers these crazy insane people have exploded.

And that now we haven’t named. We call them caring and I apologize if your name is Karen. I didn’t do it. But this is what’s happened, right?

Yes, I’ve care and there’s a carrot a table for you too. There’s a carrot at the front door. We all know what it means. I believe that difficult customers basically fall into five different categories.

They are the complainer the impatient customer, the overly demanding customer, the social butterfly and the disruptive customer which is we’re going to talk about last for sure. Let’s talk about each one of them. How you can recognize it basically how we can handle that. Now the complainer pretty self explanatory right?

This customer is never satisfied as always seems to have something negative to say. They became complain about the food, the service or any aspect of the dining experience period. And unfortunately that complainer may come in and become a repeat customer. They come in over and over again.

Or I was looking for that something free right? There’s something wrong with this dish. How do you recognize this person? They may be confrontational they may have a negative attitude.

They may make a lot of excessive demand. Now handling this person, you’ve got to listen to their complaints. apologize sincerely, and offer solutions that can rectify the issue. Sometimes it doesn’t feel good to do this.

But it’s what we did. We’re in customer service. But what about the impatient customer? This customer is always in a rush expects everything to be served quickly.

And he recognized that well they may be tapping their foot looking at their watch a lot or they just become visibly agitated because how long is going to take I’ve got a meeting to get through. I’ve got I’ve got I’ve got I’ve got it handled. Acknowledge your time constraints, and then I understand your way of offering options that can be served quickly. These are the three menu items.

I think we get you in and out for and then you need to communicate any potential delays or wait times. Hey, we’re Our kitchen is getting backed up. As you can see we’ve got a restaurants fault. It’s probably means your ticket time is going to be closer to 20 minutes.

You still want to place an order. What about the overly demanding customer. This customer’s very specific requests, right? They have very specific requests and they may want to make modification after modification after modification.

Basically taking your manual completely changing it upside down things that are not typical. And he recognized that well, pretty easy. They’re going to ask for multiple substitutions. additions or changes to a dish.

And you know, it’s reasonable say Hey, could you don’t put the avocado on that? Instead of having you know the artichokes can I replace that with something else that reasonable like they want to they want to take that dish and completely changing. How do you handle it? Well listen intently to the requests and then offer alternatives.

If it’s possible. You know, that may not work but we have this other dish that can be done or I can do this this this maybe I can’t do that. whole list of things. Well, customer, “As you can see, the restaurant is completely full.

We would not be in a position to be able to deliver that to you in a timely fashion and the way you want it. Odds are it will delay your ticket time for this table. Maybe up to an hour right you’ve got to find a way to communicate why this additional changes are not going to be a good thing and why you have certain limitations. Help.

You also need to make sure that if there’s any additional charges for these changes, they know that up front

now social butterfly this customer loves to chat. This is a time vampire. You walk up and they want to engage in a lengthy conversation with the server. Like Ah hey, you know what, I can be this person.

I don’t mean to me, but I’m gonna have fun. I’m a restaurant person I often go out to when I go speak at events like a friend Darren came in and I considered a bar and he goes David, you pull the you know, the personality out of the personality out of the bartenders because I start playing. Well, that’s a good thing. Unless you’re busy as hell.

Now I’ll tell you, I’m a restaurant Pro. I recognize when they’re busy and I don’t do it. Then. So how do you recognize this butterfly?

They may ask personal questions. They might initiate small talk and go which basically goes way beyond the typical interaction between a customer and server. How should you handle it? Be friendly and engaging.

But also set boundaries and try to redirect the conversation back to the dining experience. Hey, I’d love to tell you about my time when I when I went to the Chicago Bulls game. But we can do that a little bit later. Right now I’ve got to make sure I get your order in so everybody’s taken care of for the table.

Like teach how you get around that and last but not least we have the disruptive customer. This customer may be loud, obnoxious or disruptive to the other diners. Like you literally can hear them everywhere. They’re aggressive.

They’re just not nice people. But how do you recognize it pretty easy. They’re speaking loudly they’re using foul language. They’re behaving really inappropriately.

I’m going to tell you, even if that difficult customer isn’t dealing with you specifically, when they get loud, you need to react. You need to handle this because I can tell you somebody went to a steakhouse with my daughter and her boyfriend. We were going out visit them in Aurora, Illinois. Like there was this table that was so loud and so obnoxious.

It really destroyed our dining experience and we’re not planning on going back because the managers did nothing. How do you handle the enemy firm and when you got to be respected, as politely for them to adjust their behavior. And if necessary, seek assistance from another manager or security personnel like if you’ve got a doorman of your club or something like that and off duty officer assignment. Once you remember this your team doesn’t get paid enough to be abused.

These are your team members. Sometimes the right course of action is to actually fire your guests and invite them to never return. That’s gonna go a lot farther than the total 100 $300 might be sitting at that table has all the business that drives away the employees that you have turned over because they don’t like working there because the customers are abusive and you don’t have their back. So these are just a few examples of challenging customer types that you might encounter on a daily basis in your restaurant.

By learning how to recognize these types of customers, you can better prepare yourself to handle them effectively and provide excellent customer service. You need to know that empathy and communication are critical in dealing with these difficult customers. Empathy and communication are critical. Why is empathy so empathy is your ability to understand and share their feelings.

Right. Empathy is I feel I sharing your feelings I understand. And it’s essential. It’s essential.

It’s essential that you can empathize with this difficult customer because it shows you care about that their concerns or your concern. And by demonstrating empathy you can build rapport with that customer, which de escalates the tense situation. It creates a positive atmosphere that can help you defuse that customers frustration. How do you demonstrate empathy?

You listen actively become an active listener. Listen to their concerns. Don’t interrupt them. Don’t become defensive.

Make sure your body language by the way isn’t a turn off either. Acknowledge your feeling well, that their feelings are truly understood by saying things like I understand how frustrating that might be for you. I can see why you’re upset. because expressinging empathy through body language, such as the nodding to show, “I hear you,” making eye contact those are critically important again.

Body language is important. Don’t cross your your arms. Don’t look impatient. Don’t look away from the table.

Make sure you are truly engaged. By offering empathy you can offer a sincere apology because truly you are sorry that they’re having a bad experience. Because we’re here to create memories positive memories. We don’t want negative memories.

You could ask them now what can we do to make things right? And this is where communication comes in why communication is so important. Communication is essential in dealing with these difficult customers because it enables you to explain your position clearly. And addresses any misunderstandings.

Clear communication helps you prevent conflicts and build trust with your customers and create a positive experience that can encourage repeat business. Because I’m gonna tell you right now, when somebody has a bad experience, whether it’s your fault or not. They’re visceral. It’s deep.

It’s it’s emotional. It’s anchored in their heart in their brain right now they’re upset and they will always remember your restaurant or accent. But if you can listen, show empathy and turn that situation around. You take that same memory and it’s stuck already in their head in their heart.

You make it a positive or customer for life. Here’s some examples of how you can communicate clearly. Use clear, concise language that’s easy to understand. Like we don’t think, Oh, well, we’re so sorry.

We 86 that number 30 minutes ago, because our distributor didn’t drop it off and we didn’t mark it into our POS system. The hell did that all mean unless you were in the restaurant business. Right. Choose language they can understand.

Repeat back the customer’s concern. This ensures that they know you understood them that you’re actively listening. Avoid using jargon or technical terms that the customer may not understand. Like we talked about a moment ago, provide explanations and solutions to the concerns that customer has and ensure that well you’re going to take the steps to address the issue.

Why is building rapport and building rapport with your customers is essential in dealing with difficult customers because it helps you create a positive relationship and reduce tension. A positive relationship, good rapport with that customer also helps you prevent future conflicts. Again, these are people who can come back over and over again we don’t want that repeat customer being a pain in our ass. We’d rather than be a loyal customer that loves us.

Here’s some examples of what you might do to build rapport. Be friendly and approachable. And try to connect with your customers on a personal level. I teach us when I talk about hospitality if maybe you join me on YouTube on Fridays or Facebook on Fridays for my shoot the shit with DSP.

It’s alive. I do travel schedule permitting. But just recently I did one on customer service. And I talked about how important is to build rapport with your guests.

Don’t walk up and say hi, my name is David who cares I don’t care that your name is David. You teach that you want to create that rapport relationship first. Hey, that’s a great hat. Where’d you get that?

Oh man, I have that briefcase. Whoa, where’d you guys come from juice come from the county fair down the street this year. Kids have you know face paint on. You find something you can bond with your guests about.

And then after you take their order and you start to walk away, you turn back and say oh, by the way, my name is David. I’ll be here to take care of. Now I care about David. When you come up say Hi, my name is David.

I don’t care what that report is so important and often building that report the beginning can defuse any negative negativity right from the beginning. You want to use the customer’s name if you know their name, use all their credit card. If they’re regulars, you know their names. There’s one thing people love to hear the most and that is their name.

Make eye contact show that you’re engaged. ask open ended questions to encourage the customer to share with you their concerns and their feelings. Remember, being an active listener does not matter if they’re right or wrong. Their feelings are always right to genuine interest in the customer’s experience.

And then provide them personalized recommendation on whether it’s menu or steps that we can do to fix that. By demonstrating empathy community communicating clearly and building rapport with difficult customers in create a positive and memorable dining experience that can encourage repeat business to generate positive reviews. So here’s the deal. You’re going to have difficult customers.

What you need to do is train each and every one of your team members how to deal with these difficult customers. So that you can build your your business that you keep cheap negativity off the internet, and more importantly…

a great restaurant. Hey, that was an awesome episode. I want to thank you for taking the time to take action on building a better more prosperous restaurant. Before you go.

I want to give you these three thoughts one by combining leadership and taking action with systems and training being checked by accountability. You are on your way to creating prosperity for you and your restaurant to have something I need from you. Please leave a review on Apple podcast Spotify or wherever you happen to listen to podcasts. By leaving us a review of the restaurant pros seeking out this information you are able to find it.

I read the reviews and hearing how this information has benefited you. does wonders for me. And three. If you find any of the discussions helpful share them, the more restaurant pros who have access to them the better we become as an industry.

For more restaurant resources or to get in contact with me. com. Be passionate about what you’re doing. Be persistent, but more importantly become better and help everyone around you become better and your restaurant is going to kick some ass.

About the author

David Scott Peters

Author of The Restaurant Prosperity Formula. Restaurant coach since 2003. Dishwasher through operator through educator. I help independent restaurant owners find the one decision they’ve been avoiding — and build the systems that make the new decision stick.

More about David →

If this hit a nerve, the next step is a real conversation.

The Systems Check Call is 30 minutes with Ryan James on my team. He’s a former member who turned his own restaurant around using this work. No pitch. He’ll diagnose whether we’re the right fit — and tell you the truth either way.