When it comes to managing your restaurant’s cost, you absolutely can’t ignore labor. It is the second biggest expense in a restaurant – after an empty seat in the restaurant. Labor cost management is an essential topic for achieving restaurant prosperity and financial freedom. The last few episodes of The Restaurant Prosperity Formula podcast have been a collection of some of my best and most popular tips on three very popular categories for restaurant owners: food cost (Episode 101), systems (Episode 102) and leadership (Episode 103). In this episode of my podcast, The Restaurant Prosperity Formula, I’m serving up a collection of some of my best and most effective labor cost lessons and tips. You’ll learn how to calculate labor cost, how to manage them and how to avoid common pitfalls.
Understanding Labor Cost Calculations
To calculate your restaurant’s labor cost, you need accurate data. Remember, incorrect data leads to poor decisions. First, decide between using total gross sales or net sales. Gross sales include the total amount before discounts and taxes, while net sales deduct these. For labor cost calculations, use gross sales to measure the performance of your team based on the business’s potential earnings.
Next, distinguish between raw labor cost and total labor cost. Raw labor cost refers to the direct wages paid to employees, while total labor cost includes taxes, benefits, and insurance. Managers should focus on raw labor costs for day-to-day operations, while total labor costs are crucial for budgeting and tracking overall expenses.
Key Labor Cost Mistakes to Avoid
- Using incorrect labor targets: Arbitrary targets can lead to financial losses or inadequate staffing. Set realistic targets based on your specific needs.
- Outdated scheduling practices: Adjust your scheduling to match fluctuating sales. Avoid overstaffing during slow periods and understaffing during busy times.
- Late labor cost tracking: Monitor labor costs in real-time to make necessary adjustments promptly. Waiting until the end of the week or month is too late.
Practical Tips for Managing Labor Costs
- Use a budget: Set a budget that includes a prime cost target (total cost of goods sold plus total labor costs). Adjust your labor targets based on seasonality and sales volume.
- Proactive scheduling: Allocate hours and dollars to each department based on expected sales. This ensures you start each week on budget.
- Track running labor costs: Monitor labor costs daily and make adjustments as needed to stay within budget. Track both percentage and actual hours worked to identify areas needing improvement.
Advanced Labor Controls
- Full-time equivalents (FTEs): Ensure you have enough staff to cover shifts without resorting to overtime.
- Cross-training: Train employees to handle multiple roles. This increases flexibility and efficiency, especially during peak times.
- Operating budget maintenance: Regularly review and adjust your budget to reflect changes in your business.
Managing labor costs effectively requires a combination of accurate data, proactive scheduling, and continuous tracking. By mastering these strategies, you can significantly improve your restaurant’s profitability and efficiency.
Click the podcast player above to listen in, or you can watch the video on YouTube, click here to download the latest episode.
Read the full transcript.
Hey there restaurant pros, it’s David Scott Peters and welcome to episode 104 from season one of the Restaurant Prosperity Formula. I’ve been coaching restaurant owners since 2003 and the Restaurant Prosperity Formula is based on what the most successful restaurant owners I’ve worked with do on a daily basis to achieve their success. The basic premise of the formula centers around achieving prosperity, freedom of your restaurant and the financial freedom you deserve. To achieve prosperity, you have to follow a very specific formula made-up of leadership, systems, training, accountability, and taking action. After 100 episodes, I wanted to gather some of the most poignant content on the most important issues for restaurant owners. I started with food costs in episode 101. I covered the importance of systems in episode 102 and why leadership is the foundation to my restaurant prosperity formula in episode 103.
Episode 104, this episode is focused on labor cost. I provide you with the simple restaurant labor cost calculation. I address what to do if you find yourself short on labor. I give you some tips on budgeting for labor and how to teach your team to keep to that budget. And finally, some tips to help you quit wasting labor dollars. Whether you’re new to my podcast or a longtime listener, this is an episode you will not want to miss.
Let’s get started. But first, a word from our sponsor. We all know managing costs is one of the most important parts of running a profitable restaurant, especially now. But between fluctuating vendor prices, waste, labor, and the never-ending list of tasks that demand your attention on a daily basis, it can be challenging for even the most experienced of us to manage costs well. That’s where Margin Edge comes in. Margin Edge is a complete restaurant management software that automatically uses data from your POS and invoices to show you food and labor costs in real time. Don’t wait until it’s too late. Margin Edge gives you tools to make decisions in the moment, like a daily P&L, price alerts on key ingredients, and real-time plate costs, all without ever having to touch a spreadsheet. Take control of your costs, work more efficiently, and be more profitable. Go to www..marginedge.com forward slash DSP to learn more and schedule your demo today.
In order to calculate your restaurant’s labor cost, we need to gather the right numbers. See, the thing about calculations is garbage information in equals garbage information out. So if we gather the wrong data, we get bad results, ultimately making bad decisions in our business.
So the first thing we want to decide is Total gross sales versus total net sales, which one do we use? Gross sales is the ring of the register before the discounts have been removed, not including sales tax. So again, ring of the register, no discounts removed, doesn’t matter what the comps were. Net sales, ring of the register after the discounts, not including sales tax. Well, which one do we use? Well, I’m going to shortcut this for you and tell you it’s gross sales. Why? Because if you run any form of promotionals, discounts, employee meals, anything that are comps, we’re going to measure our team based on what the sales would have been, whether you collected the money or not. For instance, let’s say I’m planning on a $10,000 day, but I’m going to comp 50%. I’m just having a favorite charity walk in the door and I’m going to comp $5,000. Does your management team buy product for a $10,000 day? or a $5,000 day? 10. Do you use staff to handle the business for a $5,000 day or a $10,000 day? 10,000. So we’re going to use gross sales when we calculate your restaurant’s labor cost.
The second thing we’ve got to gather is really understand are we using raw labor cost versus total labor cost?
Now, what’s the difference here? Well, here’s the deal. In raw labor cost, we’re just doing the hourly wage. If I pay a cook $15 an hour, he or she punches in and punches out in one hour, $15 is what they get paid. Now that’s not what comes out of your bank account. You’ve got what? Taxes, benefits, insurance. So we’ve got to understand that the raw labor cost, that number is for my managers to follow. So when I give them a labor target, it is going to be before, or I should say, after we’ve removed taxes, benefits, insurance. Because my managers are not going to wait and sit there and calculate every employee to find out when they’ve reached their limit of FICA and SUI that they stop paying it. But they can control $15 an hour times the number of hours somebody works. where total labor cost, that’s for budgeting and tracking. That’s where we’re going to look at everything, every position, including taxes, benefits, insurance, because that is a part of my prime cost. It is a part of my labor cost. We’ll talk about prime costs in just a moment. But either way, yes, any money that comes out of your bank account based on labor is a part of your labor costs. So yes, taxes, benefits, and insurance included.
So now the third thing we’re going to understand is what is the calculation? it’s use divided by gross sales. Believe it or not, if you’ve been on my channel for any length of time, you understand that is the same calculation we use for cost of goods sold. Food costs, bottle beer, draft beer, wine, liquor, NA bev. Use divided by sales. In this case, it’s not use of product, it’s use of minutes, hours, dollars that you are going to spend in payroll. Now, remember, use divided by sales can give us very different numbers if we’re using raw labor cost, the raw wage versus total. So there’s going to be a very different way to use that.
So let me kind of paint the picture with some numbers. Let’s say your restaurant did $135,000 in gross sales last month. Your total labor cost for line employees, management, all up without any taxes, benefits, insurance, was $35,194.84. $35,000 into $135,000 gives us a raw labor cost percentage of 26.07%. Now that’s going to be important. That’s the number we are going to be measuring our management team if they did a good job or not. Again, they cannot control taxes, benefits, insurance.
But if I add those taxes, benefits, insurance back in and we use the same scenario that I did $135,000 in gross sales, But in this case, with raw labor costs, adding to it taxes, benefits, insurance, we did $42,439.37 in use, right? What our payroll was. the 42,000 into 135,000 gives us a raw labor cost of 31.44, 26 versus 31. So it’s important when we’re looking at budgeting that we understand that our total labor cost is something we have to manage as well. So we’ve got to control the whole thing. So this should answer your question on how you go about calculating your restaurant’s labor cost.
Here’s a list of common mistakes restaurant owners make when it comes to labor cost.
One, using the wrong labor targets. Hey, maybe you grabbed one out of a magazine or another video and you heard that the average full service restaurant runs a 34% labor cost. Who said you were average? You’ve got to understand where your labor target needs to be. By using one that arbitrary came out of the air, you’re setting yourself up for mistakes. Losing money or having really not enough labor to handle the business comes in.
Two, scheduling like you always do. Well, if you always do what you always did, you always get what you always got, right? If you like these results you’re getting, then keep doing it. But the truth is, you don’t like them. And our sales go up and down. And so if we schedule like we’re busy for when we’re slow, you’re bleeding labor like no tomorrow. Vice versa, if we schedule like we’re slow and we get busy, we can’t handle it and we give ****** service, get terrible Yelp reviews. Long ticket times, you get the picture.
And finally, three, looking at your labor costs when it’s too late. if you’re measuring your success at labor on a Friday afternoon and you’re working on a Monday through Sunday work week, it is far too late. You have no idea that your rookie manager was playing solitaire on a Monday and left everybody to close together when you had no business and your labor really **** the bed all the way back then. But you’re paying attention to it on a Friday. And again, on our two busiest days, we’re going to make adjustments. It’s the wrong time.
So look, To fix this, all you need to do is follow these three basics, the restaurant labor cost 101, if you will.
Number one, you got to use a budget and understand prime cost. If you need to learn about budgeting, prime cost, you’re in the right place. Make sure you check out my channel and search for many videos on prime cost, many videos on budgeting because it’s critical. See, with a budget, you set your plan up for success. You set your labor targets, understanding where your cost gets sold and labor is going to be based on where you’re located and more. So in order to schedule properly, to grab the right labor target, you’ve got to have a budget. And I’m going to tell you this, When you’re busy, your labor target will be lower than when you’re slower, it will be higher because your salaried managers chew up so much money. And we have these things called minimum staffing levels versus maximum staffing levels or efficiencies when all of a sudden we couldn’t add another cook to the line and your customers are managing your efficiencies because you’re on an hour wait. So understanding budget, understanding where your prime cost numbers should be is #1.
Number 2, schedule based on that budget. Right? Here’s the deal. We all too often bring people in. We’ve been told, hey, you want to give great service, bring in more people. Well, have you ever looked at your staff? When you have more staff than you have customers, what are they doing? They’re playing grab *** with each other, ignoring the guests. That’s when your bad Yelp reviews happen. So what we’re going to do is, using a system I teach my members called the Restaurant Payroll Guardian, we tell your managers how many hours and dollars they have to spend to go into the week on budget instead of bringing people in and praying we’re busy, sending them home if we’re slow because it’s too late. If we already had three slow hours and we start cutting people, we’ve already blown our labor budget. Instead, we’re going to discover, hey, chef, you have 350 man hours you can schedule in your kitchen. But because you’ve copied last week’s schedule, you have 364. need to cut 14 hours. Well, the first things come out of chef mouth. You got to be kidding me. We’re a scratch kitchen. I need these people. It’s hard enough to find anybody to work. And you want me to cut 2 shifts from people? No. What I want you to do is start thinking outside the box because we’re in a schedule going into the week on budget. You can’t have those hours and pray we’re busy.
Instead, you’re going to have to do things like this. Hey, what if we have the nighttime crew set up the line ready to go for the morning? that all they have to do is come in, look at a pre-done prep list. They don’t have to search and do. They can start becoming efficient right away. But we could bring in four cooks 15 minutes later in the AM shift. Hey, before we start cutting at lunch, what if we had the daytime crew switch over the line, make sure it’s 100% ready for the PM crew? Could we bring in four cooks 15 minutes later? Well, odds are we could. Well, in the morning, that’s an hour. In the evening, that’s an hour. Oh, there’s seven days a week. All of a sudden, that’s two hours a day time. Seven days a week, that’s 14 hours. we have to start thinking outside the box and asking our managers to schedule on budget.
And last but not least, #3, track your running labor cost percentage and your daily hours. Hey, we all learned track your labor costs. We know the labor cost by day and running total. In fact, most of your POS systems will tell you that story. But remember step one, When we said, hey, we’re going to have a budget, we know what our labor cost percentage is for the month, maybe higher or lower depending on that month. Well, that translates to scheduling the hours we have to right in step 2, which means we’re going to set up our schedule based on the needs of the business. We may have a higher labor cost than a Monday versus a Friday because on Monday we had our *** handed to us over the weekend. We got all this prep to do. So based on production, we’re going to have a higher labor cost because we have lower sales, but the production needs to happen. Whereas on a Friday, we have no prep and our sales are through the roof and our labor efficiency is lower. But if I use those hours that have been allocated in step 2, no more, no less. I will end the week on budget. So I schedule that way, which means I now have a different labor cost percentage and I have a trailing budget that I’m going to be following.
Well, there’s one more piece and that’s hours. See, all too often we have these sales forecasts. We expect a $5,000 day and we scheduled 300 hours, just arbitrary numbers I pulled out of the air. Well, if you approve that schedule, we know the labor cost based on that day. We already said we’re tracking percentage, but wait a second. We have 300 hours for a $5,000 day. What if the next morning you walk in and you worked 310 hours? What would your expectations be? Sales to be higher on forecast or lower? Higher, right? But you come in and it was either dead on forecast or it was actually $500 less. How is it that we needed 10 more hours? You now know which manager you need to coach to make sure they get people out of there, that they’re not wasting your money.
These 3 steps are critical. When you get the hang of it, not only will you drop your labor costs, but you’re going to get yourself ready for advanced labor controls that put you 100% in control of your time clock and your profitability.
I couldn’t add another cook. I have money, but I don’t have a station for them. I couldn’t add another server. I have the money for it, but I don’t have enough tables. And so all of a sudden, your customers start to manage your efficiency. And your labor cost drops like a rock because everybody comes in at the same time, everybody leaves at the same time because you’re busy the whole time. So you’ve got to have a budget in order to combat higher labor costs.
Now, I’m all going to tell you during that budgeting process, I do something called the down and dirty dollars per labor hour work, efficiencies.
So what it is, I may look at your budget and look at the dollar amount that you’re going to spend, say, next month, the first month of your budget. Let’s just call it that. Doesn’t matter when you start the budget. You can start it on July, August, September, January, doesn’t matter. So the first month of our template, we look at the dollar amount that we’re going to spend in a position, let’s call it cooks. And then I’m going to divide that by What? The average hourly wage for cooks. That’s going to tell me how many hours I have. I take those hours, divide that into food sales only because that’s all they touch. They don’t produce bottled beer, draft beer, wine, or liquor. And I come up with a dollars per labor hour worked. And let’s say we come up with $150 per man hour worked. So if there’s a cook on the line, just one, we’re going to do $150 in an hour. If there’s two cooks on the line, we do $300. You get the picture. So it’s per body, per hour, what we’re going to generate. Well, let’s call it $150 per labor hour worked. And then we’re going to look at your average ticket per person and how much of that is just food based on your sales percentage. If you do 80% food, we take 80% of that average ticket from your point of sale system. And let’s say we come up with $25 as the average ticket per person food only.
Well, if I divide that into 150, What is that? That’s six, six items an hour. Now there’s some flexibility there. You know, items, entrees, don’t know. Like it’s not a perfect science, but it’s pretty close because only 25% of your customers actually order a secondary item, an appetizer or a dessert. So the fact of the matter is it kind of translates pretty well. And all of a sudden you look at that and say six items an hour, basically those scheduled hours and sales.
So what we did is we walked through and I said, hey, look at this day, sale, expected sales versus actual sales, expected hours or originally scheduled hours, what was actually worked. And we could see on a consistent basis, certain days were controlled and certain days were out of budget. But nobody ever tried to get it back on budget. We just kind of tracked. And I said, I can tell you that’s probably the same manager closing. That same manager needs some coaching. So He had a great understanding of the tracker, went back to his management team, and taught them.
Now, a couple weeks later, I receive a text message from him, and literally on my phone, a text message, and it read like this, Since our chat, we’ve been hitting our labor numbers, had a weaker sales week, just finished up, still hit our targets. The labor tracker is working great.
That is what it’s all about. If you want to control your labor, it starts with a budget. It goes into proactive scheduling. But if you don’t track, you’re never going to control it.
Everything goes into running your restaurant. If you have an empty place, you’re losing money. So ultimately, the biggest expense is that empty chair. After that, I would dare say it’s labor cost. Either way, labor can be, well, a restaurant profitability killer.
Here’s a short list of seven essential tactics you must master to control your labor costs and start making the money you deserve.
Number one, understand how to use FTEs full-time equivalents when you’re making sure you have enough people to cover your schedule. Having the right amount of members on your team, on staff, virtually ensures that there’s not overtime. Even when people go on vacation, even when they ask for time off, even when you have turnover. It’s really important. And what it is, this process of making sure that you know what your scheduling needs are and it’s having two FTEs, full-time equivalents, more than you think you need based on filling the schedule so that when people take time off, when people leave, they fill in the gaps because there’s always someone asking for time off.
Number 2, Implement and train scheduling practices that eliminate, well, new managers from making the scheduling mistakes that cost you money over and over and over again. Think about every time you train a brand new manager, if you don’t give them the training they absolutely need, they make the same ******* mistakes the manager made before them, before them, before them, before them, and every time a mistake is made, it costs you money, whether ****** *** guests and lost opportunity at the register or, well, increased cost. because it’s inefficiency or mistakes are made. So it’s really important you have your system, your process, your way, and you teach it.
Number 3, add cross-training to your training systems. It’s important and imperative to have a training system in the 1st place, not just follow that guy. But the reality is when you can get, well, say, servers to cross-train to be hosts and you got bussers to cross-train to be dishwashers and you got barbacks cross-trained to be bartenders, all of a sudden, right, you get the picture? When you have a need, you’ve got the trained backup and replacement ready to go. That way when you’re caught with less people than you need on a schedule, by cross-training we become more efficient.
Another way to use cross-training would be in the kitchen where you may start somebody as a fry cook as entry level. But when they certify, they get to learn the next station, whether it’s sandwiches and salads. And when they certify there, they might get a 25 cent raise and they go to the next station and a 25 cent raise and the next station and a 25 cent raise, whatever it may be. And the truth of the matter is, all of a sudden, when they’re trained on four, five, six positions, when you have a slower day, you can get by with one, two, three cooks instead of 6 because they can handle it.
Number 4, implement and maintain an operating budget. This is so important. If you follow me any length of time, you know I say the two most important systems any restaurant should have are budgets and recipe costing cards. Why? Because they’re proactive systems. A budget creates your plan for success. The key number you must know in your budget to really control and know where your labor costs should be is prime cost, which is total cost of goods sold plus total labor costs, including taxes, benefits, and insurance. Generally speaking, I teach that if you run sales under $850,000 a year or more in sales, we’re looking at a 60% prime cost. Anything over $850,000 a year in sales, I’m shooting for a 55% prime cost or lower. That means I could run it any way I need to based on my location, my core values, the quality of product, my price point, all these type of service. So I could run, say, a 30% labor cost, which means I’d have a 25% overall cost of goods sold. I could run a 30% overall cost of goods sold, which will only give me 25% for my labor cost. See, with a budget, you’re going to know where your labor numbers should be in order for you to be profitable and to control to.
Number 5, you’ve got to implement, train, and hold managers accountable to that labor budget. with that budget, you’re going to find that your labor cost target will be different every single month based on your seasonality. In the off season, because your managers are maybe a salaried management team sucking up all the profits, you’re going to need more money to cover minimum staffing, which means you might run a 38% labor cost on purpose. But in season, when you’re doing $300,000 in sales and your management team don’t get paid, they don’t get paid any more because they’re salaried and you reach maximum efficiencies, I couldn’t add another cook, server, anybody on the floor, my labor cost as a percentage becomes really small. Maybe we’re running 19%. But overall in the budget for the year, maybe our target was 25%. But with that 38 and 19 and all the different months, you know what to budget to hit your ideal cost or labor cost for the year. So I can tell you this, a system I teach my members is called the restaurant payroll guardian that ensures you schedule on budget each and every week.
Number 6, understand your numbers and how to calculate your labor efficiencies. This is critical to make sure, well, you set up your stations properly, you’ve got training, your prep and systems in place, your menu is there, and you know what to reduce in order to hit your labor targets. by the way, all staying true to your core values. What it means is, while we want to deliver the best experience to our guests, we do have to run profitably. And when I have my budget and I’ve got my labor targets, it allows me to say, hey, if I need to reduce my labor cost, how do I do it? Often it can be, again, resetting up the line to become, instead of taking three steps to the right, I’m just turning. because you can literally put in miles. It could be reducing the menu to reduce prep. It could be reducing the menu to increase repetition that people on the line make things faster, better, more consistent. You can do this when you are looking at where to take your labor costs, but can’t do without a budget.
And finally, #7, start tracking labor like a pro. Don’t just track labor costs by day. You’ve got to keep that running total. So Monday, What’s my labor cost? Use divided by sales, labor dollars, sales. Tuesday, labor dollars, sales, and then a running total for the two. That’s important.
But I’m going to tell you one thing most people don’t do. Look at your originally scheduled hours and forecasted sales. Then at the end of the day, look at where your sales actually hit, were they higher or lower, and what were your actual hours worked? Did they go up or down? This can tell you when a manager is falling asleep at the wheel. And oh, by the way, when I track labor not only by percentage but by hours, and I track and I see that Tuesday, two days into the week, I’ve already blown my labor budget, I’ve got five more days I can make tiny little changes to get back on budget without giving up guest satisfaction or cutting on service levels.
Hey, that was an awesome episode. I want to thank you for taking the time to take action on building a better, more prosperous restaurant.
Before you go, I want to give you these three thoughts. One, by combining leadership and taking action with systems and training, being checked by accountability, you are on your way to creating prosperity for you and your restaurant. Two, I have something I need from you. Please leave a review on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you happen to listen to podcasts. By leaving us a review, other restaurant pros seeking out this information are able to find it. I read the reviews, and hearing how this information has benefited you does wonders for me. And 3, if you find any of the discussions helpful, share them. The more restaurant pros who have access to them, the better we become as an industry. For more restaurant resources or to get in contact with me, connect with me at DavidScottPeters.com. Be passionate about what you’re doing. Be persistent, but more importantly, become better and help everyone around you become better. And your restaurant is going to kick some ***.
