Episode 157 Transcript: How Small Misses Become the Standard

The Restaurant Prosperity Formula Podcast, with David Scott Peters

Hey there, restaurant pros. It’s David Scott Peters, and welcome to the Restaurant Prosperity Formula podcast. For over two decades, I’ve been guiding restaurant owners to success with the proven principles of something I call the Restaurant Prosperity Formula. I originally created the formula based on the daily practices of the most successful restaurant owners I coach, and it’s now the foundation of what I teach restaurant owners like you, so you can achieve success.

What do I mean by success? Success is a restaurant owner who dictates the terms of their life and their bank account, instead of the restaurant dictating those things for them. Success is a restaurant owner who has freedom from the restaurant and the financial freedom they never thought possible. How you define success is up to you, but I do know the way to achieve it is by using the Restaurant Prosperity Formula.

This season, I’m diving even deeper into the core elements of the formula: leadership, systems, training, accountability and taking action. Along with my insights, you’ll hear from special guests, industry experts and inspiring success stories from fellow restaurant owners who’ve turned their businesses around and found their own definition of success.

In this episode, number 157, we’re talking about how small misses become the standard in your restaurant, and how to coach the first miss before it turns into culture cost leaks and hospitality breakdowns. Let’s get started.

This episode is brought to you by Service with Style’s secret shopping program. Get comprehensive reports with photos, customized visit templates, a vast network of experienced shoppers and a scoring system so you know exactly what your guests are experiencing. You control the frequency and rotation, with no minimums, no contracts, no cancellation charges and no hidden fees. You’ll also get industry-leading reporting and scoring software, plus a 10% discount, and your first shop is free. Set up a quick call today at www.servicewithstyle.com/dsp.

Your restaurant doesn’t lower its standards all at once

It lowers them one ignored miss at a time. The sidework gets skipped, and nobody says anything. The portion is too big, and nobody corrects it. The closing checklist is half done, and nobody follows up. The guest waits too long to be greeted, and nobody coaches it. The prep list is ignored, and nobody asks why. The manager misses a labor cut, and nobody reviews it.

Every one of those misses teaches the team something. It teaches them what matters. It teaches them what doesn’t matter. It teaches them what’s actually required. It teaches them what they can get away with. And eventually, the miss is no longer the exception. It becomes the standard.

That’s what we’re talking about today: how small misses become culture, how ignored misses turn into cost leaks, hospitality breakdowns and accountability problems, and how to coach the first miss before it becomes the way your restaurant operates. Because the first miss is the coaching moment. The repeated miss is the pattern. And the ignored miss is permission.

Every restaurant pro has seen this

You walk through the restaurant and see something small. A server station isn’t reset. A bathroom check was skipped. A cook is over-portioning fries. A bartender forgot to record waste. A manager didn’t complete the shift notes. A server left without finishing sidework. The host didn’t quote the wait correctly. The line wasn’t wiped down between rushes.

Nothing dramatic. Nothing that makes the building fall over. Nothing that feels worth stopping the world for. So you let it go. You tell yourself, “I’ll deal with it later.” Or, “They know better.” Or, “It was a rough shift.” Or, “I don’t want to be nitpicky.” Or, “I’m tired of being the bad guy.” Or my favorite lie restaurant pros tell themselves: “It’s not that big a deal.”

Except it is, because it’s not the one missed task that destroys the restaurant. It doesn’t. One missed bathroom check doesn’t bankrupt you. One oversized portion doesn’t ruin food cost. One skipped sidework task doesn’t destroy culture. One missed labor cut doesn’t sink the business. One bad table touch doesn’t end hospitality forever.

But the pattern will. The repeat will. The silence will. The permission will. Because the team is always learning. The restaurant is always training them, not just through your handbook, not just through your meetings, not just through your checklists, not just through what you say in pre-shift. The restaurant trains people by what gets corrected and what gets ignored.

A miss is a test of whether the standard is real

That’s why small misses matter. A miss isn’t just a mistake. A miss is a moment where the team finds out whether the standard is real. When a standard is missed, the team looks for the response. Maybe not consciously. Maybe nobody says it out loud. But they’re watching.

Does the manager notice? Does the manager coach? Does the owner follow up? Does the standard matter when the restaurant is busy? Does it matter when the person who misses it is a strong employee? Does it matter when the manager is tired? Does it matter when the owner isn’t in the building?

That’s the test. And if nothing happens, the team learns. They learn the standard is optional. They learn the checklist is flexible. They learn the portion guide is a suggestion. They learn the labor target is a nice idea. They learn sidework only matters when somebody complains. They learn hospitality only matters when the guest gets angry. They learn accountability means nothing, or that it only means something once I finally lose my mind. And that’s not accountability. That’s delayed frustration with a soundtrack.

The three stages of a miss

Let’s break this down. There are three stages of a miss: the first miss is information, the second miss is a pattern, and the ignored miss becomes permission.

The first miss is information. When somebody misses a standard for the first time, don’t jump straight into anger. Don’t assume bad intent. Don’t immediately decide the person is lazy, careless or out to ruin your life. Maybe they were never trained. Maybe the standard wasn’t clear. Maybe the tool wasn’t visible. Maybe the manager didn’t inspect. Maybe the station was set up poorly. Maybe the rush exposed a weak process. Maybe they were guessing. Maybe they knew the task but didn’t understand why it mattered. Maybe they simply made a mistake. That happens. Restaurants are pressure machines. People miss things.

So the first miss gives you information. It tells you where to inspect. Before you blame the person, inspect the structure. Was the standard clear? Was the person trained? Did they know what “done” looks like? Was the tool where the work happens? Did someone own the follow-through? Was there a cadence? Was the miss inspected? Was the standard protected? That’s leadership, and not soft leadership, real leadership, because real leadership doesn’t just react to the symptom. It diagnoses the cause.

Say the closing checklist wasn’t completed. The lazy answer is “the closing team doesn’t care.” Maybe. But start with better questions. Was the checklist clear? Did the team know which task belonged to which person? Did the closing manager inspect before people left? Was the checklist in the right place? Was there a standard for what “completed” means? Did anyone coach the miss the last time it happened? If the answer is no, you may not have an employee problem yet. You may have an installation problem.

Same thing with food cost. Say a cook is over-portioning fries. You could say they’re wasting food. True, but ask better questions. Do they know the portion size? Is there a portion tool? Was the portion demonstrated? Is the correct scoop available? Is the manager checking plates during the shift? Has anyone explained how a little extra food on every plate turns into real dollars? If not, the first miss is information. It tells you where the standard is weak.

Same thing with hospitality. A guest waits too long to be greeted. You could say the host dropped the ball. Maybe they did. But was the greeting standard clear? What’s the time expectation? Who backs up the host when the stand gets busy? Does the manager watch the door? Was the host trained on what to say when there’s a wait? Does the team know hospitality starts before the guest sits down?

The first miss is information. Use it. Don’t ignore it. Don’t explode over it. Coach it.

The second miss is a pattern. Now we have something different. If the same person misses the same standard again, or the same task keeps getting missed by multiple people, you’re not dealing with a one-off anymore. You’re seeing a pattern, and patterns need management.

A repeated miss tells you something is still broken. Maybe the coaching wasn’t clear. Maybe the follow-up didn’t happen. Maybe the manager isn’t inspecting. Maybe the employee doesn’t believe the standard matters. Maybe the system is too complicated. Maybe the wrong person owns it. Maybe the consequence is missing.

This is where restaurant pros often fail. They notice the second miss, get annoyed, complain about it, and still don’t correct it properly. They say things like, “We’ve talked about this.” “You know better.” “I shouldn’t have to keep repeating myself.” “How hard is it to do sidework?” “Why can’t they just follow the recipe?” “Why do I have to babysit everyone?”

I get it. I really do. But frustration is not a system. Being annoyed doesn’t protect the standard. A manager venting in the office doesn’t change behavior on the floor.

The second miss needs a stronger response than the first, not louder, but stronger: more direct, more specific, more documented, more followed up. The first miss might sound like, “Here’s the standard. Here’s what happened. Here’s what needs to happen next time.” The second miss might sound like, “We coached this yesterday. It happened again today. I need to understand what’s getting in the way, because the standard is not optional.” That’s different. It says we’re not drifting. It says this is being watched. It says the old way isn’t automatically coming back.

The second miss is where you decide whether you’re going to protect the standard or negotiate with it. And be careful, because your team can smell negotiation. If you say the standard matters but tolerate the miss, they know. If the checklist matters only when you’re mad, they know. If portion control only matters when food cost is high, they know. If labor targets matter only after payroll, they know. If hospitality matters only after a bad review, they know. The team isn’t stupid. They may not say it, but they know what’s real.

An ignored miss becomes permission. This is the part that creates culture. Not the mistake. The permission.

What you don’t correct, you permit. What you permit, you teach. What you teach, you become. Read that again: what you don’t correct, you permit; what you permit, you teach; what you teach, you become.

If sidework is skipped and nothing happens, you teach that sidework is optional. If recipes are ignored and nothing happens, you teach that recipes are suggestions. If managers miss labor cuts and nothing happens, you teach that labor targets aren’t real. If the dining room isn’t inspected and nothing happens, you teach that the close is negotiable. If comps aren’t explained and nothing happens, you teach that discounts don’t require accountability. If a guest has a poor experience and nobody follows up, you teach that hospitality is reactive.

And then, months later, you look around and say, “How did we get here?” One ignored miss at a time. Culture isn’t built only on your values. Culture is built by your tolerance. It’s built by what gets repeated. It’s built by what gets protected. It’s built by what gets ignored.

That’s why the small miss matters, because the small miss is usually where culture starts drifting. Not in a dramatic moment, not in some giant betrayal. In the small stuff. The little stuff. The “we got busy” stuff. The “I’ll fix it tomorrow” stuff. The “it’s not worth the argument” stuff. The “they know what I mean” stuff. That’s where standards go to die, right there in the small misses nobody wants to coach.

How to coach it: a simple, five-part format

Let’s make this practical. I want your managers to use a simple coaching format with five parts:

1. Here’s the standard.
2. Here’s what happened.
3. Here’s why it matters.
4. Here’s what needs to happen next time.
5. Show me you understand.

That’s it. No speech, no drama, no character assassination, no sarcasm, even though I know sarcasm is tempting and sometimes deserves its own dessert menu. Just correction.

Example: the closing checklist. “Here’s the standard: before any closing server leaves, the closing manager inspects the station and signs off that sidework is complete. Here’s what happened: last night, the coffee station wasn’t reset, the trash was left full, and the opening team had to fix it. Here’s why it matters: when the close is incomplete, the opening team starts behind, the restaurant looks sloppy and the standard becomes optional. Here’s what needs to happen next time: you don’t leave until the manager inspects and signs off. Show me you understand.” That’s coaching. Not yelling, not “you guys need to do better,” because that means nothing. Better how? Better by when? Better according to whom? Specific coaching beats vague frustration every time.

Example: over-portioning. “Here’s the standard: this item gets a six-ounce portion using this scoop. Here’s what happened: during dinner, I saw multiple plates go out with portions above the standard. Here’s why it matters: over-portioning quietly raises food cost, creates inconsistency for the guest and makes the recipe costing useless. Here’s what needs to happen next time: use the correct scoop on every plate, every time, even in the rush. Show me you understand.” Clean, specific, no drama.

Example: hospitality. A host quotes 20 minutes when the actual wait is closer to 45. “Here’s the standard: quote honestly and communicate delays early. Here’s what happened: we quoted 20 minutes, the guest waited over 40, and nobody updated them. Here’s why it matters: the guest feels ignored before they even sit down, and the server starts with a frustrated table. Here’s what needs to happen next time: if the quote changes by more than 10 minutes, update the guest before they have to ask. Show me you understand.”

That’s how standards become real. They’re not real because they’re printed. They’re real because they’re coached.

Coach it fast, then follow up

The first coaching moment should be fast. That doesn’t mean reckless. It means timely. The best coaching happens close to the behavior. If you wait three weeks, you’re not coaching, you’re hosting a cold-case investigation. Nobody remembers the details, the employee gets defensive, the manager gets vague, and the standard feels random. Coach it while it’s fresh, calmly, specifically, privately when appropriate, and then follow up.

Coaching without follow-up is just a conversation wearing a manager shirt. Follow-up is where the standard gets protected. If you coach the portion standard today, someone needs to check the station tomorrow. If you coach the closing checklist tonight, somebody needs to inspect the next close. If you coach the host quote standard today, the manager needs to watch the host stand tomorrow. If you coach the waste tracker today, somebody needs to check whether it gets filled out next shift.

That’s how the team learns you mean it, not because you had one powerful conversation, but because the standard is still there tomorrow. That’s the part most restaurant pros miss. They coach once and think, “Good, handled.” Maybe. Maybe not. The team is going to test whether handled means handled. The restaurant is going to apply pressure again. The rush will come. The call-out will happen. The truck will be late. The new person will need help. The manager will get distracted. And the standard will either hold or drift. Your job is to protect it until it becomes normal.

When coaching isn’t enough: consequences

Whenever I’m teaching coaching, someone hears it as, “So we just keep coaching forever?” No. Absolutely not. Endless coaching is tolerance with a nicer outfit.

If the standard is clear, trained, owned, visible, on a cadence and coached, and the person still refuses to do the work, then you have a people problem, and now accountability has to move. That might mean a documented warning. That might mean changing someone’s role. That might mean taking a shift away. That might mean removing responsibility. That might mean termination.

You don’t protect a standard by coaching forever. You protect a standard by being fair and clear: first make sure the standard was installed, then coach the miss, then follow up, then, if the behavior doesn’t change, apply consequences. That’s not harsh. That’s leadership.

What’s harsh is making your best employees work next to people who ignore the standard and suffer no consequences. What’s harsh is making your opening team clean up after a weak close every morning. What’s harsh is letting one cook over-portion while another follows the recipe. What’s harsh is letting a manager ignore labor targets and then wondering why profit is missing. What’s harsh is telling your team standards matter while proving they don’t. That’s the stuff that damages culture. Consequences are not the enemy. Inconsistency is the enemy. Unclear standards are the enemy. Ignored misses are the enemy.

What this means for your managers

Your managers need to understand that seeing a miss and doing nothing is a decision. They may not think of it that way. They may think they’re avoiding conflict. They may think they’re being nice. They may think they’re too busy. They may think the miss is too small. But when a manager sees a standard missed and does nothing, they’ve just participated in lowering the standard. A manager who sees the miss and does nothing is not neutral. They’re teaching the team that the standard can be skipped.

That’s why managers must be trained to coach the small misses, not just the big blowups, not just the cash shortages, not just guest disasters, not just employee drama. Small misses, because small misses are where culture is shaped.

I want you to think about your restaurant right now. Where are the small misses you’ve been tolerating? What are they? Be honest, not about the giant projects or the huge strategic problems, but the small stuff, the things you walk past and silently resent, the thing your manager complains about but does nothing to fix, the thing the team knows is supposed to happen but has learned probably won’t be inspected.

Maybe it’s sidework. Maybe it’s portioning. Maybe it’s the manager log. Maybe it’s waste tracking. Maybe it’s line checks. Maybe it’s restocking. Maybe it’s table touches. Maybe it’s greeting times. Maybe it’s recipe cards. Maybe it’s labor cuts. Maybe it’s closing standards. Pick one, not all of them, one. And ask: what standard is being missed? Is it clear? Has it been trained? Who owns it? Is it visible where the work happens? When is it inspected? Has the miss been coached? What follow-up is required?

That’s the work. Not rage, not blame, not another meeting where you say, “Guys, we need to do better.” Please retire that sentence. “Do better” is not a standard. It’s a wish with a disappointed face. If you want better, define better, train better, inspect better, coach better, protect better. That’s how standards change.

Your action step

For the next seven days, I want you and your managers to use what I call a first-miss coaching note. It doesn’t need to be complicated. It can live in your manager log. It can be a section in your shift notes. It can be a simple Google Form. It can be a clipboard, if you still enjoy paper cuts and mystery handwriting. I don’t care where it lives.

But when a standard is missed, answer five questions:

1. What standard was missed?
2. Who or what was involved?
3. Was the standard clear and trained?
4. What coaching happened?
5. What follow-up is required?

That’s it. Five questions. The goal isn’t to create paperwork. The goal is to make sure the miss doesn’t disappear, because when misses disappear, patterns grow, and when patterns grow, culture changes.

For seven days, capture the first miss, not to punish people, but to see the truth. You may discover your standards aren’t clear. You may discover your managers aren’t inspecting. You may discover employees were never properly trained. You may discover one person keeps ignoring the same standard. You may discover one station is always the problem. You may discover the system is too hard to follow under pressure. Good. Now you have something to manage. That’s the point.

Closing thoughts

You cannot protect a standard you do not inspect. You cannot coach a miss you do not name. You cannot fix a pattern you refuse to see. So start small. Find one standard. Watch for the first miss. Coach it quickly. Follow up. And if it keeps happening after the standard is clear, trained and coached, then move to consequences. That’s accountability without drama. That’s leadership. And that’s how you stop small misses from becoming the standard.

Remember: the first miss is information. The second miss is a pattern. The ignored miss becomes permission. And what you permit, you teach. So be careful what your restaurant is teaching.

Remember, restaurant prosperity is about freedom for your restaurant and the financial freedom you deserve. I’m David Scott Peters. Thanks for listening to the Restaurant Prosperity Formula podcast.

There’s one number that’s quietly killing your restaurant profits, and most owners don’t even know what it should be: your prime cost. Right now, most restaurants are running at least 15 points higher than they should be, which means you’re working harder and making less than you deserve. If you’re tired of being stuck in your restaurant, tired of inconsistent or nonexistent profits, then it’s time to find out what’s really going on. I invite you to book a free 30-minute Restaurant Profit Finder call with my team, where you’ll uncover exactly what’s eating your profits and what it’s costing you every single month. Just click the link in the description to get started.