The Secret to Finding Good Restaurant Managers for the Kitchen

By David Scott Peters

·

Hiring a restaurant manager is a challenge, but there’s no greater challenge than finding the right kitchen manager. A lot of restaurant owners look to chefs as an ideal manager in the kitchen. After all, they are people destined to help create an experience in a restaurant that results in pleasure and lasting memories. But often a chef is unprepared to lead the restaurant because the higher the position a person has in a kitchen, the less they will cook. In a well-run restaurant, the title of chef is less about creativity and more about management. 

In this episode of my podcast, The Restaurant Prosperity Formula, you will learn the pitfalls to avoid when you’re looking to hire a restaurant manager in the kitchen and the traits to look for in a new hire. I’ll also teach you the kitchen manager’s true role in the restaurant and what to expect from them. And finally, you’ll learn what to do if you find a person who fits your restaurant’s culture but has some learning to do to be effective in your restaurant.

Make sure you grab a pad of paper and a pen and take notes on this one. Before I share with you what you should be looking for to make this process much easier, let’s look at the common reasons restaurant owners end up selecting the wrong person.

Avoid these in your search for a restaurant manager for the kitchen

It’s pretty easy to think you found the right person, right? You’re trying to find the right person to take over your kitchen, and you’re certain you’ve found the right person only to be disappointed again. Why is it so easy to think we found the right person?

Sometimes you’re in a bind. Maybe you’ve already been running short-staffed, you’re going into season, and you need somebody right now. You’re in a bind, feeling a little desperate, you see a good resume and experience and you go for it.

Other times you’re just tired. You lost your kitchen manager, and you’ve been in the kitchen making up those hours and then some. You don’t want to be there anymore, and the first person that can fog a mirror says they’ll accept the position so you hire them.

Sometimes you’re looking for a lifeline. Maybe you’re like me. I don’t belong in the kitchen. I can run a kitchen, order on budget and par levels. I can schedule on budget and operate off opening and closing checklists, but I have zero cooking knowledge or skills. If you’re like me and you just need a culinary pro because you’re fearful of your kitchen, you’ll take the first person who can talk the talk.

And another common scenario is you want to find a person quickly. You’re impatient and don’t let the process take its course so you hire the first person who walks in the door.  

The reality is when it comes to hiring great managers for a restaurant kitchen, more often that not, you pick the wrong person. Let’s talk about changing that outcome for you in your restaurant.

What to look for in a kitchen manager during the interview process 

  • Somebody who fits your company culture.
  • Culinary experience that matches your restaurant.
  • Knowledge about the important numbers for restaurants.
  • Experience training other team members.
  • Willing to learn.
  • Willing to do things your way.

Understands it’s your restaurant.

In the interview process, you’re seeing the absolute best this person could ever be. And I don’t know anybody who shows up every day giving their absolute 100% best possible self every single day. It won’t get any better than what you’re looking at in the interview. Don’t get discouraged. If they don’t meet the vision you had, if you’ve trained them what their job is how to do it, how well it should be done more importantly by when, and they demonstrate they got it, then it’s on them.

What to expect from the leader of your restaurant kitchen

Whether they’re a kitchen manager or a chef, the short answer is that there’s really only one difference between the two of them. When it comes to job expectations, you should expect your chef is going to have a much broader knowledge of food. From French cuisine to knife skills to being able to break down a side of beef, they will have a broad range of knowledge and culinary skills. They have an ability to train others the same way. A kitchen manager is going to manage a kitchen but may not have the culinary knowledge of a chef. But that end of the day, chef still means manager. 

  • Knows and creates all menu items offered at the restaurant upon approval from owners.
  • Provides build sheets and photographs so all staff can accurately answer menu item questions regarding preparation methods, ingredients, portion sizes and side items accompanying the dishes.
  • Sets all specifications for substitutions for items on the menu.
  • Orders on budget, following pars.
  • Calculates and compares actual to ideal food cost.
  • Maintains a level of inventory that turns four to six times a month.
  • Ensures that proper food controls are in place to maintain an appropriate level of cost of goods, within ½ percent of the target budgeted food cost.
  • Stays within line-item budgetary goals assigned to this position, following the restaurant’s annual budget.
  • Creates specials at least one week ahead of time and properly costs and prices each item.
  • Builds menu for catering, from passed appetizers to full sit down on-site and off-site events.
  • Creates specials at least one week ahead of time and properly costs and prices each item.
  • Builds menu for catering, from passed appetizers to full sit down on-site and off-site events.
  • Implements proper people practices regarding interviewing, selection, training and employee relations.
  • Meets uniform and appearance standards.
  • Maintains five-star health and sanitation rating with department of health.
  • Maintains appropriate staffing levels.
  • Controls labor within ½ percent of targeted labor cost.
  • Maintains a positive attendance record, reports for assigned shifts, 0% no call/no show.
  • Ensures ALL sanitation and safety standards are followed.
  • Encourages and develops a cooperative team environment.
  • Implements employee development plans.
  • Leads by example.

Get the full details and explanation on each of these categories in the podcast. Also tune in to hear stories about restaurant owners I’ve worked with who have had these same challenges and what they did to find someone reliable to be a restaurant manager in the kitchen.

Click the podcast player above to listen in, or you can watch the video on YouTube, click here to download the latest episode.  

Read the full transcript.

Hey there restaurant pros. It’s David Scott Peters Welcome to Episode 65 of the Restaurant Prosperity Formula. I’ve been coaching restaurant owners since 2003. And the Restaurant Prosperity Formula is based on what the most successful restaurant owners I’ve worked with do on a daily basis to achieve their success.

The basic premise of the formula centers around achieving prosperity, freedom of your restaurant and financial freedom you deserve to achieve prosperity you have to follow a very specific formula made up of leadership, systems, training, accountability and taking action. Today I want to focus on one of the biggest staffing challenges restaurant owners I talk to every day talk about on a very consistent basis. And that’s hiring a kitchen manager or chef. Restaurant owners asked me what should they be looking for in a candidate and what should they expect from them when they hire them?

Make sure you grab a pad of paper and a pen and take notes on this one. Let’s get started. Hiring a manager can be a challenge, but I think there’s no greater challenge than hiring a manager to run your kitchen. Whether that’s a kitchen manager or chef.

Let me start off by sharing with you what you should be looking for to make this process much easier. Now, before I do that, I do know that having started coaching independent restaurants back in 2003, restaurant owners and managers I’ve seen a lot and I’ve literally talked to literally 1000s of restaurant owners and managers, restaurant teams culinary Front of House doesn’t matter. And you know what? Over the past 20 years, one thing has not changed.

And that’s the challenge of finding the right kitchen manager or chef for your restaurant. Now it’s pretty easy to think you found the right person right you’re on a search you’re trying to find the right person to take over your kitchen. Why is it so easy to think we found the right person? Well, sometimes you’re in a bind, like man, I need somebody today.

We’ve already been running short staffed. I’m going to season I need somebody right now. So you’re in a bind and you you kind of see the shiny object that smile across from you that has a pretty good resume and experience. You think I’m gonna hire that person?

Sometimes you’re just tired. Anyway, you lost your kitchen manager. You’ve been in the kitchen for 80 hours. It’s not your forte don’t want to be there anymore.

And man, the first person that can fog a mirror that says will accept the position we often take them thinking oh no, no, I really found the right person. Sometimes you’re looking for a lifeline. It’s just Oh my gosh, there’s there’s chaos. It’s crazy.

Maybe you’re like me personally, I don’t belong in a kitchen. Now I can run a kitchen. I can order on budget and power levels I can schedule on budget and staff and guides I can open and close every station out for opening and closing side work checklist. Prep zero coloring skills.

Like I can work fry and Garmin Jane and we’ll in an eight minute ticket time all day long. But it can’t saute. I can’t grill knife skills are horrid. I don’t have any knowledge of basis of you know French sauces and soups and things.

I don’t have that. And maybe you’re like me, you’re like man, I just need a culinary pro because I’m fearful of my kitchen. I don’t have that knowledge. Sometimes you just really want to find a person quickly.

Like today. You’re impatient. You’ve been doing this long enough that man How can I do any worse than the last person and you hire the first person who walks in the door? That doesn’t matter why you think you found the right person?

The reality is we more than often pick the wrong person. Like man I think I got the right person then it’s like a self fulfilling prophecy. Why do I hire another kitchen manager or chef, they’re always the wrong person. Well, we’ve got to change that.

Let me give you an example of what I mean. Even for one of my highest level members a mastery plus slash member mentor somebody went to my restaurant Restaurant Transformation Intensive program. John Dempster. Now I’m gonna tell you right now I’ve got nothing but love and praise for this guy even before we met.

He’s a systems guy to begin with already had budgets and recipe costing cards all he was missing was the why the why you do things and that other things are possible instead of hitting a 34% food cost which because that’s a national average, what could his restaurant do, based on his location, price, point style, his service and so on. And his core values of course. And I can tell you that in during one of our coaching calls, it was time to move on. His chef meaning have a chef move on, as somebody started in the line with him side by side, elbow to elbow, shoulder to shoulder somebody really cares about and Mike’s is a very small community in Virginia.

But as we implemented more systems as we started to ratchet up our expectations of our management team, Chef wasn’t coming along. And in fact, truth be told, chef was probably unhappy. And it took a long time for John to come up with the conclusion was time to have the discussion with this person who was a good friend. He moved the person on and through serendipity or whatever it may be some phone calls next thing you know there’s this ideal candidate comes out of nowhere like he he didn’t even get to talk to a bunch of people how he talked to one this was the right person want a connection connected him because he doesn’t have a large pool from from the draw from because it’s a small community on the Chesapeake Bay in Virginia, like small summer resort kind of town.

And so he got on a zoom with this person and he talked them for hours. He hadn’t talked to the GM. He did some research like Man, this is the right guy. I’ve got to move on this.

So we did a coaching call and Adam is general manager and he were on a call like we need to move on this guy. we think we found an ideal guy. When we brought him on. And it wasn’t weeks.

It’s not just a couple of months when finally John said, This guy talked a great game but he delivered I’ve got to let them go. Even to a point where in their offseason because he had the time. John the owner, after letting him go went back in the kitchen to implement all the systems that weren’t being used anymore, because this guy really wasn’t what he said he was now he had patients because John’s out of season. He is now in a process of hiring another kitchen manager or sorry chef and thinks he found a good guy.

Now, does that sound familiar to you? Have you had those similar situations doesn’t matter. And again, I’m talking about a really a restaurant pro getting hit with the same situation everybody gets. So what should you look for in a kitchen pro when you’re going to go through the interview process should look for somebody with a great attitude somebody who fits your company culture, culture is extremely important.

You got to be finding out from that candidate what kind of coloring knowledge they have. Now, culinary knowledge is is going to be very important or less important depending on the concept you have if you’re looking for a kitchen manager knife skills are important, but maybe not the whole knowledge of French cuisine or how to break down a chicken completely you name it right. Whereas if you’re a fine dining restaurant, man you’ve got to have that’s a part of the art which you’ve got to train others on. So what kind of culinary knowledge matches your your restaurant?

What kind of knowledge for numbers and systems do they have right? From food costs recipe costing cards inventory, calculating yield, scheduling on budget, controlling labor, on budget, and so many other things so important that your potential kitchen leader either has a general understanding, or at least is willing to learn when you’re talking to this candidate, what kind of experience do they have training other team members because quite honestly, training is very important. The higher you move up in the food chain, the less you’re going to touch a knife you’ve got to manage and train people. You got to figure out if they’re willing to learn because again, it’s not so important.

I guess depending on your concept, how deep their knowledge is if they’re willing to learn. And that’s important because you can provide them the right training, especially on the systems and number. You got to figure out are they willing to do things your way? All too often these culinary professionals come and go it’s my way or the highway.

Well go open your own damn restaurant. They’ve got to be willing to follow your system, your ordering system, your prep system, your recipe card system, your stuff. That doesn’t mean they can’t bring improvements and you can’t bend but they can’t throw your stuff away. They can’t change things.

without your permission. Does this candidate have an understanding? Really an understanding that it is your restaurant, not theirs? And the buck stops with you from budget to all the major decisions.

Now you can give them the authority to make certain decisions but anything that’s not in their authority, they’ve got a check with you. And all things being equal.

If we want to hire the person who’s willing to learn, who do things my way and is looking to move up. When I say looking to move up instead of hiring the season chef I want that sous chef looking for the opportunity to move up instead of that kitchen manager season kitchen manager I want that well line supervisors looking for the opportunity to be move up. Why? Because ultimately I can teach the my systems my way.

I want the person who gets excited about the opportunity to move up rather than the person who’s stuck in their way saying it’s my way or the highway. Now I’m not gonna lie, even when you ask the right questions, even when you think you’re done. You’ve done all your due diligence, and even when you believe in your heart of hearts you found the right person. You have to remember the candidate that sitting in front of you is is presenting their very best self.

That means you’re seeing in the interview process the best this person can be. And I don’t know anybody who shows up every day giving their absolute 100% best possible self every single day. So do you know it doesn’t get any better than what you’re looking at? So understand.

You can get yourself into a little excitement about a person you want to hire because, again, you’re seeing the shiny object the best they can be. Just don’t get upset with yourself. If this person doesn’t work out. You had an idea of vision what they would do.

Don’t get discouraged if they don’t meet that. If you’ve trained them what their job is how to do it, how well it should be done. More importantly by when and they demonstrate they got it then it’s on them. And if it weren’t the right person, that’s okay.

You just got to be able to get back on the horse and try again. What should you expect from a leader of your team? Whether they’re a kitchen manager or a chef? The short answer is that there’s really only one difference between the two of them.

When it comes to job expectations. You should expect your chef is going to have a much broader knowledge of food, right from French cuisine to knife skills to being able to break down you know, a side of beef, a pig who knows they’ve got a broad range of knowledge and culinary skills, preparation of dishes and they have an ability to train others the same way. Basically what they know now a kitchen manager like a chef is going to manage a kitchen and see the difference is depending on how much culinary knowledge you have the chef still means manager right so the major difference between the chef and the kitchen manager is really knowledge and ability to create new menu items develop people when it comes to higher end skills. But either way, they both manage.

In fact I give a speech when I fly around the country to different shows that often. One of the favorite ones I give is Chef means manager not person who makes pretty food tastes good insert kitchen manager there doesn’t make a difference. They’re there to manage just like your front of house is that here’s a list of management expectations. You should place on your kitchen pro whether a chef or a kitchen manager.

So your kitchen pro should know and create all menu items offered at a restaurant upon basically your approval. Your kitchen Pro provides build sheets and photographs so all the staff can accurately answer the item questions regarding preparation methods ingredients portion size, and site items accompanying the dishes. Your kitchen pro sets all specifications for substitutions for items on your menu, your kitchen pro orders on budget following Pars, your kitchen pro calculates and compares actual to ideal food cost. Your kitchen pro maintains a level of inventory that basically turns your inventory in a calendar month four to six times.

Your kitchen pro ensures that the proper food controls are in place to maintain appropriate level of cost of goods sold. To be able to hit your number within a half a percent of your target budget cost of goods sold. Your kitchen pro stays well within line item budgetary goals assigned to this position. Following the restaurants annual budget, whether that’s paper supplies, janitorial smallwares you get the picture, your kitchen pro creates special lists, or I’m sorry specials if they do so, at least a week ahead of time right so we’re not making it oh it’s three o’clock we got a dinner rush coming in an hour.

What are we gonna make for a special No, I want recipe costing cards done. Have a costed properly and a price set and approved by management the general manager owner a week in advance, your kitchen broke, builds catering menus. So whatever those menus are for catering from past appetizers to sit down on site or on premise. Any of those events.

Those menus are done your kitchen pro creates specials again specials from depending on whether the kitchen manager or chef they lay them out to make sure they are built properly. Right and again not only costing but meet your needs. Your kitchen pro implements proper people practices regarding interviewing, selection, training and employee relations. Your kitchen pro meets uniform and appearance standards your kitchen pro maintains a five star health and sanitation rating with your health department.

Your kitchen pro maintains appropriate staffing levels. Your kitchen pro controls labor within a half a percent of targeted labor. Your kitchen pro maintains a positive attendance record reporting for assigned shifts a zero-percent no-call, no-show record. Your kitchen pro ensures all sanitation and safety standards are followed your kitchen pro encourages and develops a cooperative team environment.

Your kitchen pro implements employee development plans. Your kitchen pro ultimately leads by example. It’s really important that you as the owner understand what the expectations are from your culinary leader or you’ll be paying someone who doesn’t have a grasp of what’s expected of them and they will ultimately let you down even when it’s your fault. You allowed it to happen.

So what do you do? If you want to follow my advice and you hire a kitchen leader who needs more knowledge because they’ve checked off all the boxes culture fit? Check, willing to follow your systems check willing to learn check. The short answer is get them the systems and the training they need to make your restaurant the best it can be both in product quality and consistency and profitability.

Let me tell you what kind of impact training can have on your business. I have a Restaurant Transformation Intensive group coaching graduate a mastery Plus member who is again, somebody who made incredible change in their business in the program and is now sitting in my mastermind group wanting to make even more change in their business. That means they’re at the top of my food chain operators who not only have the proper mindset, but take action and get results that’s husband and wife Matt and Dasia Wakefield. They own and operate a brewery and a brew pub in Northern California.

And they have a partner who’s a small partner but partner who’s a chef Frank Frank Cordova and he’s been learning and implementing my systems through their implementer so when you go through my Restaurant Transformation Intensive program, you’ve got a sidekick if you will an implementer somebody who gets shit done, who trains everybody and implements the systems ensuring it gets done helping you to be successful. And it was on a rare occasion I’d ever have direct contact with Frank we did some menu engineering calls. We talked about finding loss in the kitchen. We talked about labor, but for the most part in a 30 week program.

I may be talking to him three times. Well, I’m going to tell you, Frank is a keeper because he embraced the systems and never gave any pushback. But his real growth was after he and Matt attended my two day seminar in Las Vegas. Let me be very clear, man Frank made an investment and a journey.

to Las Vegas. A journey to learn the systems they had already learned in a 30 week program but sometimes we learn differently sometimes you’ve got to be immersed in it and hear it directly from me the expert and after two days, immersing themselves in the budgets and food costs and labor costs systems and more. Frank came home ready to change the world. Yes, Frank had been exposed to the systems and was using the systems already.

But now with a greater understanding of the importance of the systems and the real buy in that came with it. I’m happy to report Frank is truly kicking ass and taking names. See, it goes to show you how important the training aspect is of my Restaurant Prosperity Formula. Right It starts with leadership systems, training, accountability and taking action it is a key portion of your success.

Now I hope what I shared with you today puts you on a path to have well

a well-run kitchen that builds your business and makes you money. Hey, that was an awesome episode. I want to thank you for taking the time to take action on building a better more prosperous restaurant. Before you go.

I want to give you these three thoughts. One by combining leadership and taking action with systems and training being checked by accountability. You are on your way to creating prosperity for you and your restaurant, too. I have something I need from you.

Please leave a review on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or wherever you happen to listen to podcast by leaving us a review other restaurant pros seeking out this information are able to find it. I read the reviews and hearing how this information has benefited you. does wonders for me. And three if you find any of the discussions helpful share them, the more restaurant pros who have access to them, the better we become as an industry.

For more restaurant resources or to get in contact with me. com. Be passionate about what you’re doing. Be persistent, but more importantly, become better and help everyone around.

You become better and your restaurant is going to kick some ass.

About the author

David Scott Peters

Author of The Restaurant Prosperity Formula. Restaurant coach since 2003. Dishwasher through operator through educator. I help independent restaurant owners find the one decision they’ve been avoiding — and build the systems that make the new decision stick.

More about David →

If this hit a nerve, the next step is a real conversation.

The Systems Check Call is 30 minutes with Ryan James on my team. He’s a former member who turned his own restaurant around using this work. No pitch. He’ll diagnose whether we’re the right fit — and tell you the truth either way.